What are the pros and cons of using Named vs Anonymous volumes in Docker for self-hosting?

I’ve always used “regular” Anonymous volumes, and that’s what is usually in official docker-compose.yml examples for various apps:

volumes:
  - ./myAppDataFolder:/data

where myAppDataFolder/ is in the same folder as the docker-compose.yml file.

As a self-hoster I find this neat and tidy; my docker folder has a subfolder for each app. Each app folder has a docker-compose.yml, .env and one or more data-folders. I version-control the compose files, and back up the data folders.

However some apps have docker-compose.yml examples using named volumes:

services:
  mealie:
    volumes:
      - mealie-data:/app/data/
volumes:
  mealie-data:

I had to google documentation https://docs.docker.com/engine/storage/volumes/ to find that the volume is actually called mealie_mealie-data

$ docker volume ls
DRIVER    VOLUME NAME
...
local     mealie_mealie-data

and it is stored in /var/lib/docker/volumes/mealie_mealie-data/_data

$ docker volume inspect mealie_mealie-data
...
  "Mountpoint": "/var/lib/docker/volumes/mealie_mealie-data/_data",
...

I tried googling the why of named volumes, but most answers were talking about things that sounded very enterprise’y, docker swarms, and how all state information should be stored in “the database” so you shouldnt need to ever touch the actual files backing the volume for any container.

So to summarize: Named volumes, why? Or why not? What are your preferences? Given the context that we are self-hosting, and not running huge enterprise clusters.

  • vegetaaaaaaa@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    5
    ·
    3 hours ago
    • step 1: use named volumes
    • step 2: stop your containers or just wait for them to crash/stop unnoticed for some reason
    • step 3: run docker system prune --all as one should do periodically to clean up the garbage docker leaves on your system. Lose all your data (this will delete even named volumes if they are not in use by a running container)
    • step 4: never use named or anonymous volumes again, use bind mounts

    The fact that you absolutely need to run docker system prune --all regularly to get rid of GBs of unused layers, test containers, etc, combined with the fact that it deletes explicitely named volumes makes them too unsafe for my taste. Just use bind mounts.